All Your Perfects – Shared Review

Reviewed by AshleyHow to review a Colleen Hoover book: write, erase, repeat until you’re a basket case. Why? Because nothing I say about Colleen’s writing will ever properly convey my feelings about her books. Lucky for her, my reviews have no merit (ha!) on her success. Colleen doesn’t need us to sell her books, she barely needs blurbs anymore! The back cover of her books could all say, “Read this book,” from here on out and we would mindlessly stumble to the bookstore like a hoard of zombies on The Walking Dead. Colleen’s writing is tried and true. She allows her readers to open their hearts to possibilities they’ve likely never considered, feel all the feels, and close the book enlightened and refreshed.

Despite all the good, I was still scared of reading this book. In a lot of ways, I feel like the world discourages people from getting married, starting families, and enjoying the good that comes from having a loving relationship. After reading the blurb, I was worried this would be another story to give marriage a bad name. Clearly, I should trust Colleen more. She’s always the first to brag on her #legit husband and constantly has good things to say about her family.


Quinn and Graham’s perfect love is threatened by their imperfect marriage. The memories, mistakes, and secrets that they have built up over the years are now tearing them apart. The one thing that could save them might also be the very thing that pushes their marriage beyond the point of repair.

All Your Perfects is a profound novel about a damaged couple whose potential future hinges on promises made in the past. This is a heartbreaking page-turner that asks: Can a resounding love with a perfect beginning survive a lifetime between two imperfect people?

My favorite thing about All Your Perfects were the imperfections. Fear not, as usual, Colleen’s writing is flawless and her storytelling sucked me in from the first sentence. However, Graham and Quinn’s relationship is imperfect, just like the rest of our human relationships, and it was absolutely refreshing! Most romance books take us on unimaginable journies with beautiful people, beautiful places, and whirlwind love stories. Don’t get me wrong, I like these books, too! It’s nice to escape reality and read a happy story, realistic or not, every now and then. In some ways, however, these stories may be setting us up for failure in our real lives, especially if we expect our own stories to be as perfect as the ones we read. The majority of books end as the characters get married or the epilogue will feature the characters with their 2.5 children and a tender happily ever after. Colleen Hoover takes her readers past the happily ever after to the middle of marriage, something I have never experienced in a romance novel before.

Whether we struggle in our relationships in the same way as Graham and Quinn, I think their story is real and relatable for every married couple and offers a practical look for anyone considering a long-term relationship in their lifetime. As much as we might wish it were true, life isn’t a romance novel. Life is hard, messy, and love isn’t perfect because people aren’t perfect. The beauty of marriage comes from choosing to love during the mess and despite imperfections.

While there are many obvious themes in this story, the main theme that stood out to me was communication and it’s importance in relationships. Without it, negative thoughts and resentment build up over time, leading to a huge barrier between people that eventually feels impossible to climb. Colleen’s writing makes this concept clear as day while showing how the majority of problems could have been avoided if the characters talked things out, something all of us could learn from.

I’m so thankful for the opportunity to read this beautiful and sobering look at life and love. I appreciate the lessons Colleen infused into this story – Loving the life you live and loving the person you love. She takes readers back to the basics after life has left things muddled. This will be a story that sticks with me for life.

Be sure to pick up All Your Perfects upon its release on July 17, 2018!

Happy Reading - ashley

IMG_2187editedReviewed by Sabrina

Colleen Hoover is hands down one of my favorite authors. Actually, 5171 Miles Book Blog wouldn’t even exist if it wasn’t for me discovering Slammed and then letting Ashley know about this awesome story.
I was really disappointed when I picked up Without Merit last year, though (you may remember my review from that time). In my eyes, it was the worst book she has ever written. But having a favorite author is just like having a favorite band or singer: you can’t love all the songs by your favorite artist, there is always going to that one song you don’t like at all. And this is how it is with Without Merit. And only because I didn’t like one book, doesn’t mean I don’t like her as an author anymore.

Then came All Your Perfects. Honestly, I was reluctant to pick it up. I was downright anxious to start reading it because I didn’t want it to be another book fail. But let me ease your mind now: All Your Perfects is way better than Without Merit. However, I don’t think that All Your Perfects was amazing, either. To me, Hoover’s latest novel was an okay read. It was not perfect but it wasn’t bad either.

Let’s get to the good first.
I don’t know how that woman does it but every time I read a book by her, I seem to flow through it. Her writing style is so impeccable and pronounced, it is so easy to get through any of her books – even if she writes about the most sad and depressing things ever. You just want more and more, and then all of a sudden you have only 30 pages left and you think “How can it be over already?” Reading a Hoover book is so easy and effortless, it’s the best thing.

Another positive thing about this book was Graham. Boy is that man amazing. He instantly made it on the list of my favorite book-boyfriends. There’s no way anyone can not like this guy: he’s charming, handsome, committed, kind, attentive, smart, funny, and so loving. He made this book special.

I also really liked the alternating Now and Then chapters. It gave us the perfect comparison between Quinn & Graham Then and Quinn & Graham Now.

And what is a Colleen Hoover book without conveying important wisdom and advice? Exactly, it won’t be a real Colleen Hoover book. The advice she gives is obviously customized to the characters’ lives and circumstances. However, all advice can easily be transferred into real life, our real life as a reader and I love that about her books.

People can’t always control who their circumstances lead them into.

Now to the bad part. Well, it’s not really bad but it’s something I found super annoying: Quinn. I know her circumstances are horrible and sad but I couldn’t take her constant whining, it was downright depressing and so annoying. I was dreading the Now chapters and was always glad when I finally got to read another Then chapter.
I also didn’t like the way Quinn treated Graham. He was probably one of the most perfect guys to be out there and she didn’t appreciate him at all. If you read the book, you know that Graham made some mistakes too and I didn’t like that either but Quinn should have been more appreciative to have a guy like him.

The ending seemed a little rushed and not believable if you ask me. All of a sudden everything was perfect again as if nothing happened. I wished that would’ve been handled a little differently.
As I mentioned in the beginning, All Your Perfects was not bad but it was also not perfect, it was just okay. And honestly if it wasn’t for Graham I don’t know how this book would have turned out. I’m glad Colleen Hoover found her roots again but she can still do better in my opinion.

Happy Reading - sabrina

Amazon US – ebook
Amazon US – paperback

Amazon UK – paperback

Amazon DE – ebook
Amazon DE – paperback

Follow us!
Instagram | Facebook |
 Twitter | Goodreads Ashley | Goodreads Sabrina


420 thoughts on “All Your Perfects – Shared Review

Add yours

  1. I loved your review. Especially the beginning “write, erase, repeat”. I have several authors whose books I have to do that for. I can’t wait to read this one because of the subject and the fact that Colleen writes it in such a different way.


  2. Love this review ❤ This book is one of the books on top of my wishlist and now, after reading this review, I want to read it even more 🙂 Love Colleens books and I´m sure I´ll love this one too.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: June Recap
  4. Pingback: September Recap

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: